Friday, December 27, 2024

The Unyielding Quest: Somaliland’s Path to International Recognition: by Abdulkadir Mohamoud Sugal

The Unyielding Quest: Somaliland’s Path to International Recognition

For over three decades, Somaliland has stood as an anomaly in the Horn of Africa—a self-declared republic with functioning democratic institutions, relative stability, and economic ambitions, yet without a seat at the table of nations. The contrast with the volatile landscape of Somalia is stark, and Somaliland’s quest for recognition has become a litmus test for the international community’s commitment to rewarding peace and good governance in an often-chaotic region.

A Legacy of Sovereignty

Somaliland's claim to independence is deeply rooted in history. Once a British protectorate, Somaliland gained independence on June 26, 1960, joining Italian Somaliland days later to form the Somali Republic. However, the union was fraught with tension, culminating in decades of marginalization and brutal repression under the Siad Barre regime. When Somalia collapsed into civil war in 1991, Somaliland seized the moment to reclaim its sovereignty, declaring independence and charting its own path.

Unlike many self-declared states, Somaliland has not descended into chaos. Instead, it has built a robust political framework and maintained stability, a feat that eludes many internationally recognized nations. Its argument for recognition is as much about historical justice as it is about pragmatic governance.

Democracy in the Desert

While Somalia’s federal government struggles to assert control beyond Mogadishu, Somaliland has quietly fostered a democracy that would be the envy of many nations. Presidential, parliamentary, and local council elections—some hailed as free and fair by international observers—have solidified its reputation as a bastion of democracy in the region.

Notably, Somaliland’s peaceful transfer of power in 2010, when then-President Dahir Riyale conceded defeat to Ahmed Mohamed Mohamoud “Silanyo,” showcased its maturity as a political entity. The recent elections have continued this tradition, further strengthening Somaliland’s credibility as a legitimate state.

Economic Growth and Strategic Ambitions

Somaliland’s economic strategy is as ambitious as its political aspirations. At the heart of this plan is the Berbera Port, a critical trade gateway on the Gulf of Aden. Partnering with global logistics giant DP World, Somaliland aims to transform Berbera into a regional trade hub, rivaling Djibouti.

Beyond infrastructure, Somaliland is tapping into its untapped natural resources, particularly in the energy sector. Foreign investment is gradually trickling in, with the potential for oil exploration and renewable energy projects offering a lifeline for economic diversification.

But economic development alone cannot guarantee recognition. Somaliland’s location—at the crossroads of Africa and the Middle East—makes it a strategic ally for any country concerned with maritime security, counter-piracy, and regional stability. Yet, despite these advantages, global powers remain hesitant to formally endorse its independence.

The Politics of Recognition

The African Union’s (AU) policy of respecting colonial-era borders has been Somaliland’s primary hurdle. Recognizing Somaliland could set a precedent for secessionist movements across the continent, challenging the post-colonial order.

Furthermore, Somalia’s vehement opposition complicates matters. Mogadishu views Somaliland’s independence as a threat to its territorial integrity and leverages international sympathy for its ongoing struggles to stymie Somaliland’s diplomatic efforts.

However, some nations have shown quiet support. Ethiopia, while officially adhering to the AU’s position, maintains strong bilateral ties with Somaliland. The United Arab Emirates has invested heavily in the Berbera Port and military installations. Western nations, particularly the UK and the United States, engage Somaliland as a partner on counter-terrorism and development, though they stop short of formal recognition.

A Moral Imperative

Somaliland’s case presents a moral and pragmatic dilemma for the international community. Should a peaceful, democratic entity be denied recognition simply because it disrupts the status quo? Somaliland has demonstrated that it can govern itself effectively, provide for its people, and contribute to regional stability. Yet, it remains in diplomatic limbo, while failed states receive international aid and legitimacy.

As the world grapples with shifting alliances and a renewed focus on the Horn of Africa, the question of Somaliland’s recognition becomes ever more pressing. The West, in particular, must decide whether its rhetoric about supporting democracy and stability aligns with its actions.

The Way Forward

For Somaliland, the path to recognition will not be easy. It must continue to strengthen its democratic institutions, enhance its economic prospects, and deepen its strategic partnerships. Engaging the African Union remains critical, as does leveraging the support of influential diaspora communities.

But the onus also lies on the international community to recognize the reality on the ground. Somaliland is a model of resilience and governance in a troubled region. Denying its sovereignty not only undermines its progress but sends a dangerous message: that peace and democracy are less valued than maintaining outdated geopolitical norms.

Somaliland is ready for the world. The question is: is the world ready for Somaliland?